zdr.
> KStati po povodu "Oborony" - sm. klassnuyu recenziyu
> na poslednego Egora (mnoi k sozhaleniyu ne slyshannogo)
> http://www.zhurnal.ru/music/mv/nevynosi.htm
Nu zashel. Namutil obe recenzii.( i o solncevorote i o nevynosimoi
legkosti bytia). v nih menya (lichno) v chastnosti
obvinyaut v "liberalnom podonke" i v tom chto prodal revolutsiu za
korzinu absorbcii.
> Tol'ko davaite bez diskussii po povodu: fashist-ne fashist,
> kommunist-ne kommunist, prodalsya - ne prodalsya,
> mudak - ne mudak...
to est' kak bez diskussii? eto chto ne imeet ni hera nikakogo
znachenia ? u chuvaka
partbilet nomer 3 v partii nacional-bolshevikov . na nego drochit tolpa
podrostkov (panki,psevdopanki,PTU-shniki,ne znau kto eshe ) i vosprinimaet
ego pesni i rechi kak rukovodstvo k deistviu. Znau v tom chisle po
lichnomu opytu.
a to chto ne prodalsya ,eto ponyatno - on ideinyi.(eshe odna versia - s
uma soshel , no eto ne dovod, "vse my tut ne v svoem ume ").
a esli zdes' problema russkogo fashizma kazhetsya dalekoi i
neaktuallnoi , to eto iz-za razdelyaushego Izrail i Rossiu rasstoyania
i vremeni .
> Roker ! Talantlivyi ! I vse tut ....
talant, bllin. talant - vaashe vesh sub'ektivnaya . No esli sravnivat' s
ego starymi veshami (tollko slova ,muziku poslednih 2-x albomov ya pochti
ne slyshal) t.e. do
100 let odinochestva vkluchitellno , to egor ispisalsya . konchilsya .
emu vse vremya hochetsya byt' samym otricatelnym personazhem na
"rock-scene" (blyad',zvuchit kak Pesnya-88) ,no pesnyami on uzhe nikogo
shokirovat' ne smozhet ,vse uzhe privykli , ego raspevaut vse "sloi
naselenia v pionerskih lageryah i t.p. Poetomu,vidimo, on pytaetsya
shokirovat' politicheskim extremizmom . (to zhe samoe - Limonov - nu chto
on mozhet eshe skazat' v literature , vot geroi i perehodit k delu ).
Pobeda - sama po sebe pesnya ne poluchivshayasya , igra ne chuvstvah
(pri etom u menya lichno net osobyh simpatii ni k legitimnomu diktatu ni
TEM BOLEE k ranennym barkashovcam)
Rodina - deistvitellno sdelana talantlivo , vpolne katit na gimn
russkogo nacionalizma (prostota ,melodichnost',ideinost') ,no ,blyad',
eto zhe gimn dvizhenia,vrazhdebnogo mne lichno ,tak kakogo hera ya
dolzhen s etogo tashitsya.
a luchshaya pesnya letova poslednego desyatiletia -"Ofelia".
Gr.
---- Russian Rock in Israel mailing list home page can be found at http://www.wisdom.weizmann.ac.il/~vassilii/ru-rock-in-il/To unsubscribe, please send mail to majordomo@lists.neystadt.org with only the following line in the message body (NOT SUBJECT!): unsubscribe ru-rock-in-il
This archive was generated by hypermail 2.1.3 : Sat 17 Sep 2005 - 00:29:09 IDT