Michael Yutsis <michael.y@sapiens.com> writes:
> Hi!
zdras'te.
> Michael Livshin wrote:
> >
> > u Jethro Tull est' tol'ko 2 (propis'yu: dva) al'boma, podhodyaschih
> > pod opredelenie "edinoe proizvedenie": Thick as a Brick & A Passion
> > Play. Malenkie otryvochki iz nih popadayutsya na otdel'nyh sborkah,
> > no eto ne tipichno.
> > vse ostal'nye al'bomy Jethro Tull -- eto prosto sborniki pesen.
>
> FIGNYA.
>
> Po krainei mere, Aqualung - eto NE prosto sbornik pesen.
hmmm, nu vtoraya polovina, mozhet byt -- tam obyedinyayuschey temoy
yavlyayutsya texty.
navernoe, stoit poyasnit'. nekotorye al'bomy vosprinimayutsya
"tzel'no" iz-za vsyakogo roda artefaktov: pesni zvuchat pohozhe tak
kak zapisany/svedeny v odnoy i toy zhe studii, sygrany odnimi i temi
zhe lyud'mi, sochineny v odno i tozhe vremya pod odnimi i temi zhe
vliyaniyami, etc.
tem ne menee, sam fact togo chto ya, skazhem, paru pesen s Aqualung'a
ne perevarivayu, ne meshaet mne lyubit' i taschits'ya s Mother Goose,
naprimer. chto, po krayney mere v moih glazah, oznachaet chto
Aqualung _ne_ yavlyaetsya tzel'nym proizvedeniem.
[ dlinnuyu rugan' po povodu obyedineniya kuchi horoshey i raznoy
musyki pod debil'nym terminom "art-rock" ya, pozhalyu, opuschu. ]
-- (only legal replies to this address are accepted)programmer, n: A red eyed, mumbling mammal capable of conversing with inanimate monsters.
---- Russian Rock in Israel mailing list -info, unsubscribe: http://www.tarunz.org/~vassilii/ru-rock-in-il/ -hypermail archive: http://www.tarunz.org/~vassilii/ru-rock-in-il/archive/
This archive was generated by hypermail 2.1.3 : Sat 17 Sep 2005 - 00:29:18 IDT