ya obnaruzhil, chto sluchaino otpravil eto eto pis'mo ne v list...
-------- Original Message --------
Subject: Re: po vsem voprosam
Date: Tue, 05 Sep 2000 15:20:49 +0200
From: Michael Yutsis <michael.y@sapiens.com>
To: Michael Livshin <mlivshin@yahoo.com>
References:
<LAW2-F162iixjnzi95H0000214e@hotmail.com><s37l8ruqjb.fsf@bigfoot.com>
<39B4E18D.20DE8722@sapiens.com> <s31yyzuky0.fsf@bigfoot.com>
Michael Livshin wrote:
>
> > Po krainei mere, Aqualung - eto NE prosto sbornik pesen.
> hmmm, nu vtoraya polovina, mozhet byt -- tam obyedinyayuschey temoy
> yavlyayutsya texty.
I pervaya polovina - tozhe. Sm. epigraf k al'bomu, napr.
http://archvlsi.ics.forth.gr/~papathan/personal/
Bez zaglavnoi pesni, gde opisyvaetsya sam Aqualung, da i bez sleduyuschei - pro
kosoglazuyu Meri - net togo al'boma.
> navernoe, stoit poyasnit'. nekotorye al'bomy vosprinimayutsya
> "tzel'no" iz-za vsyakogo roda artefaktov: pesni zvuchat pohozhe tak
> kak zapisany/svedeny v odnoy i toy zhe studii, sygrany odnimi i temi
> zhe lyud'mi, sochineny v odno i tozhe vremya pod odnimi i temi zhe
> vliyaniyami, etc.
A esli etogo net, est' takoe ponyatie, kak obschaya ideya. Dostatochno, chtoby
byt' cel'nym al'bomom?
> tem ne menee, sam fact togo chto ya, skazhem, paru pesen s Aqualung'a
> ne perevarivayu, ne meshaet mne lyubit' i taschits'ya s Mother Goose,
> naprimer. chto, po krayney mere v moih glazah, oznachaet chto
> Aqualung _ne_ yavlyaetsya tzel'nym proizvedeniem.
Ya by skazal tak: esli by muzykanty stavili pered soboi zadachu sdelat' Akvalang
proizvedeniem, cel'nym v muzykal'nom smysle, mozhno bylo by skazat', chto eto im
ne udalos'. No ya pro eto ne slyshal. A konceptual'no - est', est' to obschee,
chto delaet etot al'bom bOl'shim, chem prosto sbornik pesen. Hot' i ne tak
sil'no, kak v "Thick...".
-- WBR, M.Y. ---- Russian Rock in Israel mailing list -info, unsubscribe: http://www.tarunz.org/~vassilii/ru-rock-in-il/ -hypermail archive: http://www.tarunz.org/~vassilii/ru-rock-in-il/archive/
This archive was generated by hypermail 2.1.3 : Sat 17 Sep 2005 - 00:29:18 IDT